|
Post by Les on Mar 20, 2019 10:48:18 GMT
rokerreport.sbnation.com/2019/3/20/18273456/fan-letters-the-levels-of-negativity-displayed-by-some-sunderland-supporters-is-alarming“The levels of negativity displayed by some Sunderland supporters is alarming...”Dear Roker Report I read today the excellent points made by Ken regarding the criticism of Will Grigg. I’d go further, the general level of negativity displayed by a percentage of our support is frankly alarming. Let’s think of the obvious for a moment, as of KO on Saturday automatic promotion was in entirely within our own grasp, we’re at a Wembley final, have ownership who appear to have the club and supporters at heart, an improving team on the pitch and a young manager hungry for success with a reputation soaring by the week. WHAT IS THERE TO BE NEGATIVE ABOUT? Ed’s Note [JN]: Thanks for your letter, Alan. I think everyone reading that last sentence did so in their loudest and most glorious Mackem accent. I agree, so many of us are far too quick to jump back onto negativity when things don’t go our way, and at times some people are downright toxic in their abuse. However, maybe this can be explained by two factors; experiencing the long-term downtrodden hopes and (mis)fortunes of Sunderland over the last decade - particularly the first two years - and secondly, heightened expectations. If we finish any lower than first, this season will statistically be recorded as the lowest point in our history, and even finishing first would be the joint-lowest. Despite the renewed life and hope at the club, watching a team who genuinely fight for the shirt win most weeks, it is a fact hard to ignore. Many have renewed expectations thanks to the hard work of the club and players this season in turning the oil tanker around. I don’t want to defend this negativity, and I do not feel it myself (I’ve personally loved League One), but I just want to try and look into the minds of those who do offer such negativity. To them, I say just enjoy the ride. We are at Wembley, automatic promotion is in our own hands and we finally have the soul of our club back - no longer is it a rotting carcass left alone to fester through apathy and mismanagement from the boardroom to the stands, via the pitch. I’ll never understand why people proclaim to love their team constantly barrage the players and don’t allow themselves a second of relief or happiness at watching a team made up by a core of local, academy Lads succeeding and winning games regularly for what seems like the first time in an age. League One is an unpredictable thrill ride, and I am 100% convinced with our continued, loyal backing (from the vast, vast majority) the Lads will end up on the right side of the automatic promotion places.
|
|
|
Post by eathummous on Mar 20, 2019 16:07:48 GMT
I don't think that the situation going into this season was worse than the situation going into the 1987/88 season. The difference was that we stormed the division in 87/88 and we haven't this time.
Last time we had Denis Smith - a forward thinking manager who turned the team into an attacking force and got us back to the top flight within three seasons. This time we have Jack Ross who is an altogether more cautious manager and he hasn't created a team that captures the imagination.
Also last time we had Marco as a talisman. This time we don't really have anyone who we can be confident can rip teams apart.
I think supporters are right to get frustrated that we haven't done better this season.
|
|
|
Post by Les on Mar 20, 2019 17:02:12 GMT
For us not to have bought a striker/s capable of scoring in this league in two transfer windows is very alarming for me.
Every club has to have at least one talisman in their ranks we have no one.
|
|
|
Post by macmackem on Mar 20, 2019 17:35:24 GMT
For us not to have bought a striker/s capable of scoring in this league in two transfer windows is very alarming for me. Every club has to have at least one talisman in their ranks we have no one. I think Griggs will produce the goods, IF we provide the ammo Les, the team are not playing to his strengths.
|
|
|
Post by Les on Mar 20, 2019 18:09:12 GMT
For us not to have bought a striker/s capable of scoring in this league in two transfer windows is very alarming for me. Every club has to have at least one talisman in their ranks we have no one. I think Griggs will produce the goods, IF we provide the ammo Les, the team are not playing to his strengths. You might be right Ray but there are less than eight weeks left of this season for him and the team to come good.
|
|
|
Post by polyphemus on Mar 21, 2019 7:28:17 GMT
For us not to have bought a striker/s capable of scoring in this league in two transfer windows is very alarming for me. Every club has to have at least one talisman in their ranks we have no one. But we did have one, but circumstances, unfortunately, forced us into selling Maja.
|
|
|
Post by boilerman on Mar 21, 2019 8:31:30 GMT
I do think with the team we have that we should be sitting in the automatic promotion spots at this time, however I the upheaval at the start of the summer, losing Maja, injuries to Wyke that have given him a stop start season, teams raising their games against us, I then think well we still have a good chance of automatic promotion and overall our record is decent just the draws that have killed us really.
|
|
|
Post by sisyphus on Mar 21, 2019 9:55:01 GMT
I don't think that the situation going into this season was worse than the situation going into the 1987/88 season. The difference was that we stormed the division in 87/88 and we haven't this time. Last time we had Denis Smith - a forward thinking manager who turned the team into an attacking force and got us back to the top flight within three seasons. This time we have Jack Ross who is an altogether more cautious manager and he hasn't created a team that captures the imagination. Also last time we had Marco as a talisman. This time we don't really have anyone who we can be confident can rip teams apart. I think supporters are right to get frustrated that we haven't done better this season. With a half decent manager we wouldn't have been playing in Division 3 at all, Stokoe proved that when he took over at the arse end of 86/87. Smith was experienced at that level. He knew exactly what it would take & set his teams out accordingly. The season started with players of the calibre of Agboola, Bennett, Procter, Gates, Owers & Armstrong, all of whom would walk into the team we have right now. As the season went on Smith realised we needed more & went out & got the likes of Marco & McPhail in. Social media wasn't about. The fans still complained when things weren't going according to plan, but extended winning runs always soothed things over. Only once have we had a winning run this time that could be termed as extended. The football since October has, by and large, been laboured at best. Even the happy clappers realise that this team has serious limitations & will struggle at a higher level. Add in five seasons of utter rubbish, allowing for the Poyet Cup Final & Allardyce 6 month upturn, and it really is little wonder that the air of negativity surrounding the club has not dissipated.
|
|
|
Post by Les on Mar 21, 2019 12:32:13 GMT
I do think with the team we have that we should be sitting in the automatic promotion spots at this time, however I the upheaval at the start of the summer, losing Maja, injuries to Wyke that have given him a stop start season, teams raising their games against us, I then think well we still have a good chance of automatic promotion and overall our record is decent just the draws that have killed us really. I agree boiler but the league table doesn't lie and for whatever reason our strikers are not stepping up to the plate. Even Catts is putting them to shame for goodness sake.
|
|
|
Post by Les on Mar 21, 2019 12:37:41 GMT
For us not to have bought a striker/s capable of scoring in this league in two transfer windows is very alarming for me. Every club has to have at least one talisman in their ranks we have no one. But we did have one, but circumstances, unfortunately, forced us into selling Maja.We replaced a proven striker with Grigg who has failed to make an impact - whether that's the fault of the manager or the player is debatable but either way they should be talking to each other to find a solution.
|
|
|
Post by boilerman on Mar 22, 2019 8:22:45 GMT
I might be wrong but the service Grigg receives most matches is sparce, I would prefer 2 up front, high tempo and just going for it but not sure how good that would be. I would give Sterling a go as well impact sub for 20 mins or a start lets see what he can do.
The team we have bar maybe 4 players or so is a League 1 team and would get relegated if this team was in the Championship, we just need to get out of this division.
|
|
|
Post by sisyphus on Mar 22, 2019 9:03:41 GMT
I might be wrong but the service Grigg receives most matches is sparce, I would prefer 2 up front, high tempo and just going for it but not sure how good that would be. I would give Sterling a go as well impact sub for 20 mins or a start lets see what he can do. The team we have bar maybe 4 players or so is a League 1 team and would get relegated if this team was in the Championship, we just need to get out of this division. The service to Maja was also sparse, especially so after the Barnsley game, he made better use of it though. Don't get me wrong, I think Grigg is a better player than Maja, but he won't score as many goals with the service he receives. Doubt very much wether you'll see anything of Sterling, unless it's a wide angle shot of the bench. No sure who's idea it was to sign him, but Ross clearly doesn't rate him.
|
|
|
Post by polyphemus on Mar 25, 2019 8:29:31 GMT
Comparisons with our only previous foray into this league are, in my view, flawed.
Then the clubs main source of income was through the gates with a little merchandising and some sponsorship from Vaux. Sky didn't exist. Wages were based on what the Club could afford and our players that survived the drop were on second tier pay.
That's a rather different background to the scenario that are new owners are having to deal with though now there are parachute payments that help to mitigate the financial damage a little.
|
|
|
Post by boilerman on Mar 27, 2019 7:44:35 GMT
Saw this article and sums up my thoughts perfectly. www.a-love-supreme.com/single-post/2019/03/26/I’m-Not-Going-To-WembleyI'm Not Going To WembleyMarch 26, 2019 | By Joe Ramage While tens of thousands head south I’ll be one of the few who will make the tea-time reservations with my Mam this Mothering Sunday despite Sunderland gracing the hallowed Wembley turf – but why? When I was growing up and being set a sail on this life-long journey that is supporting Sunderland by my Dad some 20 odd years ago, the thought of dismissing an appearance at Wembley in a cup final would have been sacrilege of the highest order – and yet here we are. A week which culminates in the capital and 90-ninety minutes of football for the opportunity to walk up those illustrious Wembley stairs and lift some silverware for the first time in nearly 46-years – who wouldn’t be excited, enthused and whatever else that should accommodate such an occasion? Unfortunately, I just cannot get invested in this competition or even the aura of a Wembley weekend because of it. What was once a relatively respected competition, albeit still a lower league competition, the Checkatrade Trophy has fallen victim to the Premier League’s iron fist of ruling over football with the inclusion of reserve teams over the past three seasons and while we as a club have accepted the invitation and sent out reserves teams in the competition in previous years that should still not be the case. A competition mixing first teams and second string teams just doesn’t strike me much as an important competition – more of a training exercise, an inconvenience or a hypothetical view to an unwanted future of league football including B teams. In the run-up to the final some here at ALS towers have been sharing their views and memories of the clubs previous jaunts to the big smoke to see Sunderland under the arch in cup or Play-Off finals which have reaffirmed my lack of interest about this Checkatrade Trophy final. To me, a cup final at Wembley should represent a childhood dream. A ‘pinch me I can’t believe this is happening’ moment – something the Checkatrade Trophy does not offer. In 2014 I got to fulfil that dream for the League Cup final against Manchester City. The eagerness and excitement and disbelief began in the January after the first leg of the semi-final against Manchester United. A 2-1 win meant the tie was far from over but it was enough of a carrot dangled in front of me to presumptuously book hotels in London for cup final weekend ‘just in case.’ The second leg at Old Trafford is probably the greatest night I’ve had following Sunderland in my 20 year match-going tenure. I was literally in tears of joy and incredulity. We’d taken out Chelsea and Man United along the way and I was actually going to see Sunderland at Wembley in a cup final and we were going to win it [and not a reserve team in sight]. The weeks succeeding were just full of adrenaline and anticipation – my Leeds and Barnsley supporting friends at university were absolutely pig sick of me talking about Wembley – until the day finally came to join the red and white exodus to London. Red and white scarves and shirts and flags decorated the A1 from Durham to Borehamwood where we parked the car before training in. Then there was THAT Saturday night. Stepping out of Leicester Square tube station on a Saturday night in London and somewhere distinctly in the distance the chorus of “Sunderland, Sunderland, Sunderland,” echoing around the West End still prompts the hairs on my arms to stand upright when reminiscing. Covent Garden was overrun with a Mackem twang. Songs were sung. Beers were emptied down throats [apart from Brown Ale] all in immaculate taste and there wasn’t a Man City fan to be seen. Sunderland had taken over. Cup final day brought with it a monumental hangover and emotions I’d never experienced. Nervous anticipation. Hope. Optimism. Fear. Christ is this happening? The hangover was replaced by tears in the eyes again on a Wembley way as Sunderland shirts new and old filled the horizon. Christ, is this happening? After the pictures and gawping and reality checks it was time to head in and to the seat. The Sunderland end packed out and in full voice long before kick off as the City contingent flitted in just in time for kick off as though they were accustomed to the Wembley nostalgia now they were rich and mint. The cup which was up for grabs was twirled around above our heads in a quite spectacular acrobatic show as the backing track grew louder and louder and the fire displays added to the drama. The teams walked out. The tears returned. The national anthem was sung while arm-in-arm with friends. Christ, is this happening? The rest, of course, is history. The result didn’t go our way but we took the lead. A gigantic big silver-League Cup-shaped carrot this time was dangled for 55-minutes and the performance was outstanding to a man. I was almost inconsolable on the tube back to the hotel having convinced myself it was our time. There is still a little bit of my heart which breaks whenever I think back to that game. But that is what a cup final and an appearance at Wembley should be. Something that can consume you like that weekend in 2014 did for me. The Checkatrade Trophy unfortunately gets nowhere near. A competition which is not even regarded as relevant to the FA when disciplining players for red cards. Irrespective of the Checkatrade Trophy being a devalued competition in its own right, it is also a competition symbolic of Sunderland’s fall in the last two years. While the “we are where we deserve to be” mentality is justified [because we are] there comes a certain point where a little arrogance and self-indulgence must prevail. What I mean by that is we as fans should be looking above and beyond competitions such as this and League One for that matter. Six times champions of England. Twice FA Cup winners. Frequent in the Premier League. This is Sunderland. Of course we deserve to be in League One at the moment due to the complete negligence and incompetence of former owners, managers and players over the past two years. But this is only the second time in the clubs near 140-year history that has been the case so let’s not believe this as the norm or accept staying here. That is in no way scrutinising the current regime of owners, managers, staff or players as, with the exception of a select few of the playing staff, they have played no part in Sunderland’s demise – and those who have are at least rolling their sleeves up and trying to rectify it this season. It is a perspective that, in the end, Sunderland are better than this. The novelty of playing sides we never have done before and visiting grounds that in reality are unequipped to welcome the amount of fans we bring has quickly worn off. The shit refereeing. The shocking gamesmanship tactics from the opposition. The poor standard. Playing reserve teams in competitive games. I don’t class this season as an enjoyment. I’m not content at ‘just winning games again’ because it is at this level. I just want to get out of this division as quickly as possible and get back to something like a season we can appreciate – or at least a season under the radar away from embarrassment and despair. As a result of Sunday’s final, another league fixture has had to be rescheduled in the shape of Burton Albion at home; adding another game to an already littered April. Currently five points adrift of Barnsley in second – potentially eight by the time we return to league action on Wednesday week – the game overload in April could be the difference between automatic promotion and being in the Play-Offs where promotion is far from guaranteed and another, much more important, trip to Wembley a possibility. Now I’m not taking a shot at any of the 40,000 strong going to London this weekend. By all means go and enjoy it. Take your children [if you have them] and make memories. But let’s not laud this win [if it happens] as something of significance. It is a competition we are participating in due to how shit we are – and that’s not something I enjoy. Of course I will be tuned in and watching on Sunday and of course I will want Sunderland to win just as I do every week. But the following Wednesday’s game at Accrington is so much more important, as is Rochdale and Burton and Coventry and Doncaster and Peterborough and Portsmouth and Fleetwood and Southend. Those are the games that will ensure we don’t have to compete in a questionable competition – a competition boycotted by its regular competitor’s fans in the future. There has been cases where winning this trophy has encouraged teams to go on to promotion and better things thereafter – look no further than Southampton following their triumph in the original, tolerable version of this competition nine years ago. I hope that we can follow in their footsteps over the next number of seasons. But for now, let’s just go down there, enjoy your weekends, get it won [sending a message to Portsmouth in the process], no injuries and get a run of crucial victories in the league snowballing as a result and maybe I’ll accept it accompanying the League One title on the bus parade come May… now where’s my tin ha
|
|
|
Post by Gordon Armstrong on Mar 27, 2019 15:31:34 GMT
Joe's my mate, I've known him for virtually all of his life - his dad used to stand next to me in the Fulwell End - and he's not usually like this
|
|